Magpye
Oops But Yum Pie
Oops But Yum Pie
Couldn't load pickup availability
Deliciously Imperfect Pies
Every now and then, a pie doesn’t pass our cosmetic standards — but still tastes exactly as it should.
These are pies with minor aesthetic quirks: a crack, a rustic crimp, or a small-batch trial that didn’t make the main run. The filling and flavour remain uncompromised.
• Lucky dip flavour
• Max 2 per order
• Limited availability
A small win for your wallet. A big win against food waste.
INGREDIENTS
INGREDIENTS
Varies depending on pie - check label when it arrives!
NUTRITION
NUTRITION
Varies depending on pie - check label when it arrives!
Share
- 5 stars: 41 (95%)
- 4 stars: 1 (2%)
- 3 stars: 1 (2%)
- 2 stars: 0 (0%)
- 1 star: 0 (0%)
Scrumptious!
I love a mystery pie! Great value too!
Love the idea of Oops but Yum! Just as delicious!
don't know what was oops about these pies. I thought they were perfectly delicious
Lovely pies
Minimal damage to crust so a complete bargain,
Hard to tell the difference between these and the full price ones!
Totally awesome pie.
Delish
Really enjoyed the pies and as a meat eater I will definitely be back for more
All very good
Can’t imagine what the ‘oops’ was, seemed fine to me!
Great value and as usual I couldn't spot the difference between it and the full-price equivalent.
Great pies, great pastry, highly recommended. 10/10.
Honestly couldn't see the oops at all. Delicious.
The chikn and leek pie was delicious.
Defo oops but YUMMY
Bargain if you see them- the ones I bought just had a split in the top- still just as tasty!
Tasty filling, great pasty, highly recommended.
Great value.. I couldn't see anything wrong with the pie to be honest and it tasted great.
Absolutely delicious, the pastry is wonderful and there is lots of filling which is so, so tasty. I will definitely be ordering more in the future
Lovely idea, to have a random pie with the order. They are all so well made that whichever recipe you get, it'll be great.
I couldn't see/taste the Oops! The flavour was as good as the regular version - thanks for the bargain...
Great value random pie, not sure what makes them "oops" because there's nothing wrong with them at all!
The fillings and pastry are Perfect. 10/10.
Great pie at a top price
Better value overall
Delicious
I bought two, delicious wish i could have had more.
Was hoping to have two different pies but still great!
A real bargain. An excellent scheme to stop waste, although I couldn't spot the defect in either of the pies I had!
Best pastry I've ever had - anywhere. This was a Mushroom and garlic filling and - in my opinion - the best of the pies I ordered.
We also got the Mac cheese which was amazing.
Love a bargain
Love em, i will be ordering more.
Absolutely delicious
