Oops But Yum! – Deliciously Imperfect Pies 🥧✨
Not every pie is picture-perfect, but they’re all just as tasty! Oops But Yum! pies might have a little crack, a pastry leak, or an uneven crimp, or even be a small test batch that didn’t quite make production but they’re still packed with the same delicious fillings and handmade pastry you love.
🎲 What You Need to Know:
✅ Same great taste, just not as pretty
✅ Lucky dip – you won’t know what you’re getting!
✅ Only £2.90 per pie
✅ Max 2 per order – limited availability!
At Magpye, we hate food waste, so instead of letting these pies go, we’re giving them a chance to shine at a bargain price.
Grab yours today—once they’re gone, they’re gone!
Anonymous (verified owner) –
It’s good to know that pies that don’t meet the usual standard of presentation do not get wasted . Very tasty
Anonymous (verified owner) –
Sue Black (verified owner) –
Bran Braniff (verified owner) –
Lovely.
Maxine G. (verified owner) –
Fabulous pies, you wouldn’t think these were oops pies, need to improve communication though.
Fiona O. (verified owner) –
Haven’t tried these yet, but we expect them to be as tasty as the rest. So, in anticipation …
Anonymous (verified owner) –
Dugie Eyton-Hughes (verified owner) –
OK, but not one of my favourites.
Tom (verified owner) –
Anonymous (verified owner) –
Kate (verified owner) –
Such a great idea! Still great pie and nice to have a surprise flavour!
David Reynolds (verified owner) –
Janette (verified owner) –
very tasty.
Barbara C. (verified owner) –
Absolutely delicious
Paul B. (verified owner) –
Love em, i will be ordering more.
Julie D. (verified owner) –
Love a bargain
Carriann Baker (verified owner) –
We also got the Mac cheese which was amazing.
Eileen Nicholson (verified owner) –
Best pastry I’ve ever had – anywhere. This was a Mushroom and garlic filling and – in my opinion – the best of the pies I ordered.
Anonymous (verified owner) –
A real bargain. An excellent scheme to stop waste, although I couldn’t spot the defect in either of the pies I had!
Alistair IW Campbell (verified owner) –
Was hoping to have two different pies but still great!
Paul Bennett. (verified owner) –
I bought two, delicious wish i could have had more.
Susan Brereton (verified owner) –
Ellen Finney (verified owner) –
Delicious
Terri (verified owner) –
Better value overall
Darren (verified owner) –
Great pie at a top price
Paul B. (verified owner) –
The fillings and pastry are Perfect. 10/10.
Rachel Faulkner (verified owner) –
Great value random pie, not sure what makes them “oops” because there’s nothing wrong with them at all!
Anonymous (verified owner) –
I couldn’t see/taste the Oops! The flavour was as good as the regular version – thanks for the bargain…
C G Malone (verified owner) –
Lovely idea, to have a random pie with the order. They are all so well made that whichever recipe you get, it’ll be great.
Tricia R. (verified owner) –
Absolutely delicious, the pastry is wonderful and there is lots of filling which is so, so tasty. I will definitely be ordering more in the future
Lisa Bond (verified owner) –
Great value.. I couldn’t see anything wrong with the pie to be honest and it tasted great.
Paul B. (verified owner) –
Tasty filling, great pasty, highly recommended.
Nicola (verified owner) –
Bargain if you see them- the ones I bought just had a split in the top- still just as tasty!